On 17 September 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union delivered a landmark judgment in case C-197/25, which may be of significant importance for businesses that paid civil law transactions tax (PCC) in connection with the transformation of a partnership. The ruling makes it possible to re-examine PCC already paid and, in certain cases, may provide grounds for seeking a tax refund.
What is the issue?
The doubts concerned situations in which a company changed its legal form and the partners made no new contributions. Despite the absence of any additional capital commitment, PCC could be charged on the value of the assets taken as the tax base in connection with the transformation.
In practice, this meant that the tax could also cover value accumulated in the course of the business, not only new contributions from the partners.
What does the CJEU judgment say?
Case C-197/25 concerned the transformation of a limited partnership (spółka komandytowa) into a general partnership (spółka jawna) without any new contributions being made. The Court referred to the EU rules on the taxation of capital raising, pointing to the limits on levying tax in such circumstances.
The ruling may be an important argument for taxpayers who paid PCC on similar transformations. It does not, however, mean an automatic tax refund in every case — each case requires an individual assessment.
Who should review their tax settlements?
In particular, it is worth reviewing your situation where:
- a partnership was transformed into another partnership;
- no new contributions were made on transformation;
- PCC was charged on the value of the company’s assets;
- the tax has already been paid and the case may still be subject to the relevant refund procedure.
The key factors are the transformation documents, the amount of the tax base and how it was determined, and the time limits laid down in the regulations.
In some cases, it may be possible to apply for a declaration of overpayment and a tax refund. Before taking action, however, you should establish the date of payment and how PCC was settled, and check whether a final tax decision has been issued in the case. These circumstances may affect the choice of the appropriate procedure and the applicable time limits.
Conclusion for businesses: if your company paid PCC in connection with a transformation, it is worth reviewing the documentation and checking whether there are grounds for recovering the tax. The CJEU judgment may be of significant importance for such settlements.
Basis: judgment of the Court of Justice of 17 September 2026, case C-197/25
